I was reminded about this by a Twitter conversation this morning, and realised that I hadn’t updated my spreadsheet about the gender of guests on Have I Got News For You since the last series ended. That the last series was pretty underwhelming may have had something to do with it, but if you’re the sort of person who wants to see a lot of statistics about how many men and women have been on the show in its 46(!) seasons, then you can find it by clicking here.
The main points (I hesitate to use ‘highlights’) are:
We still have to look back to 1997 for the last time all the guests on a show were women.
There have now been 181 times during the show’s history where all the guests (and hence, everyone on screen) was a man.
The last series managed to have 30% of women hosts and guests, which meant there was a very slight upturn in the overall percentages of both – 23.27% (guests) and 23.72% (hosts).
And it’s very depressing to compile these figures and see that there’s been basically no change since 1990.
I noticed someone on Twitter last night point out that yet again, everyone appearing on Have I Got News For You was male. This piqued my interest, and I decided to take a look and see how HIGNFY had done over its existence in balancing representation of men and women.
The answer appears to be ‘not very well at all’.
Using the information from here, I went through each of the 44(!) seasons, looking at how many spaces there were for guests and how many of those guests were female. I also looked at how many episodes featured an entirely male guest line up, how many had entirely female guests and how many were mixed. From series 24 onwards, after Angus Deayton left, I also looked at the guest hosts and the male/female breakdown of them for each season. The results can be seen in this spreadsheet.
Of course, there’s also the institutional bias that means there’s a guaranteed 2 or 3 men (Ian, Paul and Angus) appearing in each episode, so remember that all of these figures have to be seen in that light.
Some ‘highlights’ from the figures:
On average, 23.27% of guests are women (219 out of a total of 941).
Similarly, 23.16% of guest hosts are women (41 out of a total of 177).
The highest percentage of female guests in a series was 37.5% – in series 1. The next highest was series 42 with 36.67%.
Series 42 was the first ever (and, to date, only) to feature a female guest in every episode.
The first ever episode featured two female guests. There have only been six other episodes with entirely female guests, with the last one in 1997 (season 13). There have been a total of 177 entirely male episodes, with the last one yesterday.
The lowest percentage of female guests was 8.33% in series 11.
Aside from a bit of a dip in the mid-90s of which series 11 is the nadir, I don’t spot much of a trend in the figures, though the number of female hosts per series has been creeping up slightly recently. However, as women aren’t 23% of the population, the figures do show that there’s much less chance of a woman appearing on the show than there is for a man. As an example, the total number of shows hosted by women (41) is the same as the number hosted by one of Alexander Armstrong (21), Jeremy Clarkson (10) or Jack Dee (10).
(I’m sure there’s much more that can be done with these figures, so please feel free to take and use them as you wish, just please credit me with them. I’ll attempt to keep them updated as much as possible.)